
1. This is a story about believing in something and the two very different men who taught me how. It took a long time to write. It took me to churches and synagogues, to the suburbs and the city, to the “us” versus “them” that divides faith around the world. And finally, it took me home, to a sanctuary filled with people, to a casket made of pine, to a pulpit that was empty. In the beginning, there was a question. It became a last request. “Will you do my eulogy?“ And, as is often the case with faith, I thought I was being asked a favor, when in fact I was being given one.
2. Adam hid in the Garden of Eden. Moses tried to substitute his brother. Jonah jumped a boat and was swallowed by a whale. Man likes to run from God. It’s a tradition. But I was headed in the other direction.
3. “My thoughts are not your thoughts. Neither are your ways my ways. For as the heavens are higher than the earth. So are my ways higher than your ways. And my thoughts higher than your thoughts”.
4. A: Do you believe in God?
B: “Yes, I do.”
A: Do you ever speak to God?
B: “On a regular basis.”
A: What do you say?
B: “These days?” He sighed, then half-sang his answer. “These days I say, ‘God, I know I’m going to see You soon. And we’ll have some nice conversations. But meanwhile, God, if you’re gonna taaake me, take me already. And if You’re gonna leee-ave me here’”—he opened his hands and looked to the ceiling—“‘maybe give me the strength to do what should be done.’”
5. I had dreams of traveling, making foreign friends in foreign cities. I had heard the phrase “citizen of the world.” I wanted to be one.
6. Personally, I preferred the cramped brick building of my youth, where you smelled kitchen aromas when you walked in the back door. I knew every inch of that place. Even the mop closet, where we used to hide as kids. Where I once hid from the Reb. But what stays the same in life?
7. "Well, hellooo, Mitchell. It’s so nice to have you back where you belong…”
8. I meant no disrespect. It’s just that I had always felt that rabbis, priests, pastors, any cleric, really, lived on a plane between mortal ground and heavenly sky. God up there. Us down here. Them in between.
9. I scribbled a note. The most inspirational man I knew only reached his potential by helping a child reach his.
10. “When that time comes,” he said, “I think you’ll know what to say”.
11. “Mitch,” he said, “faith is about doing. You are how you act, not just how you believe”.
12. Now, the Reb didn’t merely practice his rituals; he carved his daily life from them. If he wasn’t praying, he was studying—a major part of his faith—or doing charity or visiting the sick. It made for a more predictable life, perhaps even a dull one by American standards. After all, we are conditioned to reject the “same old routine.” We’re supposed to keep things new, fresh. The Reb wasn’t into fresh.
13. But there was something calming about his pious life, the way he puttered from one custom to the next; the way certain hours held certain acts; the way every autumn he built a sukkah hut with its roof open to the stars; the way every week he embraced the Sabbath, breaking the world down to six days and one day, six days and one.
14. As we walked to the front door that day, I felt a wave of guilt. I’d once had rituals; I’d ignored them for decades. These days, I didn’t do a single thing that tied me to my faith. Oh, I had an exciting life. Traveled a lot. Met interesting people. But my daily routines—work out, scan the news, check email—were self-serving, not roped to tradition. To what was I connected? A favorite TV show? The morning paper? My work demanded flexibility. Ritual was the opposite.
15. I still didn’t get it. I was one of those disappointing congregants. Why had he l chosen me to be part of his death, when I had probably let him down in life? One more question, I said.
A: How do you not get cynical?
B: “There is no room for cynicism in this line of work”.
A: But people are so flawed. They ignore ritual, they ignore faith—they even ignore you. Don’t you get tired of trying?
B: “Mitch, that’s what faith is. If they spit in your face, you say it must be raining. But you still come back tomorrow”.
16. A: “When we spoke a few weeks ago, I asked you what you thought about your parents. Do you remember?”
B: Sort of, I say.
A: “I asked if you felt they were perfect, or if they needed improvement. And do you remember what you said?”
I freeze.
A: “You said they weren’t perfect, but…”
He nods at me. Go ahead. Speak.
B: But they don’t need improvement? I say.
B: “But they don’t need improvement. This is very insightful. Do you know why?”
A: No, I say.
B: “Because it means you are willing to accept people as they are. Nobody is perfect. Not even Mom and Dad. That’s okay”.
17. But I felt a need to keep visiting, to ensure that my words would still reflect who he was. And, okay. There was more. He had stirred up something in me that had been dormant for a long time. He was always celebrating what he called “our beautiful faith.” When others said such things, I felt uneasy, not wanting to be lumped in with any group that closely. But seeing him so—what’s the word?—joyous, I guess, at his age, was appealing. Maybe the faith didn’t mean that much to me, but it did to him, you could see how it put him at peace. I didn’t know many people at peace.
18. So I kept coming. We talked. We laughed. We read through his old sermons and discussed their relevance. I found I could share almost anything with Reb. He had a way of looking you in the eye and making you feel the world had stopped and you were all that was in it. Maybe this was his gift to the job. Or maybe it was the job’s gift to him.
19. The Reb—who often said “ego” was the biggest threat to a clergyman—held no such envy for where he’d once been. Upon retirement, he voluntarily moved out of his large office and into a smaller one. And one Sabbath morning, he left his favorite chair on the dais and took a.seat beside his wife in the back row of the sanctuary. The congregation was stunned.
20. "We were part of each other’s lives. If someone was about to slip, someone else could catch him. That’s the critical idea behind a congregation. We call it a Kehillah Kedoshah—a sacred community. We’re losing that now. The suburbs have changed things. Everyone has a car. Everyone has a million things scheduled. How can you look out for your neighbor? You’re lucky to get a family to sit down for a meal together”.
21. The Reb didn’t do short. He didn’t do email. “In an email, how can I tell if something is wrong?” he said. “They can write anything. I want to see them. If not, I want to hear them. If I can’t see them or hear them, how can I help them?”
22. A: How do you know God exists?
B: “First, make the case against Him”.
23. “When you come to the end, that’s where God begins”.
24. My friends, if we tend to the things that are important in life, if we are right with those we love and behave in line with our faith, our lives will not be cursed with the aching throb of unfulfilled business. Our words will always be sincere, our embraces will be tight. We will never wallow in the agony of ‘I could have, I should have.’ We can sleep in a storm. And when it’s time, our good-byes will be complete.
25. I knew depression was real, and in many cases required medical attention. I also knew we overused the word. Much of what we called “depression” was really dissatisfaction, a result of setting a bar impossibly high or expecting treasures that we weren’t willing to work for. I knew people whose unbearable source of misery was their weight, their baldness, their lack of advancement in a workplace, or their inability to find the perfect mate, even if they themselves did not behave like one. To these people, unhappiness was a condition, an intolerable state of affairs. If pills could help, pills were taken. But pills were not going to change the fundamental problem in the construction. Wanting what you can’t have. Looking for self-worth in the mirror. Layering work on top of work and still wondering why you weren’t satisfied—before working some more.
26. The Reb never popped a pill for his peace of mind. He loved to smile. He avoided anger. He was never haunted by “Why am I here?” He knew why he was here, he said: to give to others, to celebrate God, and to enjoy and honor the world he was put in. His morning prayers began with “Thank you, Lord, for returning my soul to me”. When you start that way, the rest of the day is a bonus.
27. A: What makes a man happy?
B: “Be satisfied. Be grateful. For what you have. For the love you receive. And for what God has given you”.
28. God and the decision He renders is correct. God doesn’t punish anyone out of the blue. God knows what He is doing.
29. “I have what I need,” he said, surveying his messy shelves. “Why bother chasing more?”
30. What profits a man if he gains the whole world, but loses his soul?
31. Getting old, we can deal with. Being old is the problem.
32. What do you do when death’s natural pecking order puts you in the front of the line, when you no longer can hide behind “It’s not my turn?“
33. A: What do people fear most about death?
B: Fear? Well, for one thing, what happens next? Where do we go? Is it what we imagined?
A: That’s big
B: Yes. But there’s something else. Being forgotten.
34. The second death. To think that you died and no one would remember you. I wondered if this was why we tried so hard to make our mark in America. To be known. Names quickly blur and in time are forgotten.
35. A: How then, can you avoid the second death?
B: In the short run, the answer is simple. Family. It is through my family that I hope to live on for a few generations. When they remember me, I live on. When they pray for me, I live on. All the memories we have made, the laughs and the tears.
36. This is why, faith is so important. It is a rope for us all to grab, up and down the mountain. I may not be remembered in so many years. But what I believe and have taught—about God, about our tradition—that can go on. It comes from my parents and their parents before them. And if it stretches to my grandchildren and to their grandchildren, then we are all, connected.
37. Jesus said, “Therefore do not worry about tomorrow, for tomorrow will worry about itself”. God don’t care about nobuilding. He cares about you, and what’s in your heart.
38. A: Can you predict which marriages will survive?
B: Sometimes. If they’re communicating well, they have a good chance. If they have a similar belief system, similar values, they have a good chance
A: What about love?
B: Love they should always have. But love changes. Love—the infatuation kind—‘he’s so handsome, she’s so beautiful’—that can shrivel. As soon as something goes wrong, that kind of love can fly out the window. On the other hand, a true love can enrich itself. It gets tested and grows stronger.
39. When she says, ‘How can you ask if I love you? Look at all I’ve done with you. What else would you call it?’ That kind of love—the kind you realize you already have by the life you’ve created together—that’s the kind that lasts.
40. Remember, the only difference between ‘marital’ and ‘martial’ is where you put the ‘i.’
41. “I think people expect too much from marriage today,” he said. “They expect perfection. Every moment should be bliss. That’s TV or movies. But that is not the human experience. Like Sarah says, twenty good minutes here, forty good minutes there, it adds up to something beautiful. The trick is when things aren’t so great, you don’t junk the whole thing. It’s okay to have an argument. It’s okay that the other one nudges you a little, bothers you a little. It’s part of being close to someone“.
42. A: But the joy you get from that same closeness—when you watch your children, when you wake up and smile at each other—that, as our tradition teaches us, is a blessing. People forget that
B: Why do they forget it?
A: Because the word ‘commitment’ has lost its meaning. I’m old enough to remember when it used to be a positive. A committed person was someone to be admired. He was loyal and.steady. Now a commitment is something you avoid. You don’t want to tie yourself down. It’s the same with faith, by the way. We don’t want to get stuck having to go to services all the time, or having to follow all the rules. We don’t want to commit to God. We’ll take Him when we need Him, or when things are going good. But real commitment? That requires staying power—in faith and in marriage
B: And if you don’t commit?
A: Your choice. But you miss what’s on the other side
B: What’s on the other side?
A: Ah. A happiness you cannot find alone.
43. I don’t care if you’re drunk, or you just left the drug house, I don’t care. When I’m sick, I go to the emergency room. And if the problem continues, I go again. So whatever’s ailing you, let this church be your emergency room. Until you get the healing, don’t stop coming.
44. Our faith tells us to do charitable acts and to aid the poor in our community. That is being righteous, no matter who you help.
45. Soon we had tumbled into a most fundamental debate. How can different religions coexist? If one faith believes one thing, and another believes something else, how can they both be correct? And does one religion have the right—or even the obligation—to try to convert the other?
46. A: How can you—a cleric—be so open-minded?
B: Look. I know what I believe. It’s in my soul. But I constantly tell our people: you should be convinced of the authenticity of what you have, but you must also be humble enough to say that we don’t know everything. And since we don’t know everything, we must accept that another person may believe something else. I’m not being original here, Mitch. Most religions teach us to love our neighbor.
47. You can touch everything and be connected to nothing. I knew airports better than I knew local neighborhoods. I knew more names in other area codes than I did on my block. The “community” I had joined was the community of the workplace. Friends were through work. Conversation was about work. Most of my socialization came through work.
48. And without the work connection, the human ties released, like magnets losing their attraction. We promised to keep up, but the promises were not kept. Some people behaved as if unemployment were contagious. Anyhow, without the commonality of work—the complaints, the gossip—how much was there to talk about?
49. I thought about my connections in life. I thought about workplace friends who were fired, or had quit due to illness. Who comforted them? Where did they go? Not to me. Not to their former bosses. Often, it seemed, they were helped by their churches or temples. Members took up collections. They cooked meals. They gave money to pay bills. They did it with love, empathy, and the knowledge that it was part of the supportive undercarriage of a “sacred community,” like the ones the Reb spoke about, like the one I guess I had once belonged to, even if I didn’t realize it.
50. What do you do when you lose a loved one too quickly? When you have no time to prepare before, suddenly, that soul is gone?
51. A: Did you feel guilty cursing God—you, of all people?
B: No, because even in doing so, I was recognizing there was a greater power than me. And that is how I began to heal.
52. My friends, when sometimes we are asked why does someone perish, someone so young in age, I can only fall back on the wisdom of our tradition. It is true that David did not live long for his day. But while he lived, David taught, inspired, and left us a great spiritual legacy, including the Book of Psalms. One of those Psalms, the twenty-third, is read sometimes at funerals.
"The Lord is my shepherd; I shall not want. He maketh me to lie down in green pastures:
He leadeth me beside the still waters.
He restoreth my soul…"
53. It’s amazing how folks can’t see you, ’cause they want to keep you in that past. Some of our greatest problems in ministering to people is that they knew us back before we came to the Lord—The same thing with Paul… They saw him… They couldn’t believe that this man’s from Jesus, because they looked at his past—They just looked at his past. And when we’re still looking at ourselves through our past, we’re not seeing what God has done. What He can do! We’re notseeing the little things that happen in our lives—
54. You knew me. You knew that person, but you don’t know the person that I’m trying to become.
55. When you give, you get.
56. I assumed a Man of God had no choice. His religion obliged him toward what Lincoln called “the better angels of our nature”. On the other hand, Napoleon once dismissed religion as “what keeps the poor from murdering the rich”. Meaning, without the fear of God—or literally the hell we might have to pay—the rest of us would just take what we wanted.
57. A: Do you think it’s true, that our nature is evil?
B: No. I believe there is goodness in man
A: So we do have better angels?
B: Deep down, yes
A: Then why do we do so many bad things?
B: Because one thing God gave us—and I’m afraid it’s at times a little too much—is free will. Freedom to choose. I believe He gave us everything needed to build a beautiful world, if we choose wisely
A: But we can also choose badly. And we can mess things up something awful
A: Can man change between good and evil?
B: In both directions.
58. From the beginning, God said, ‘I’m gonna put this world into your hands. If I run.everything, then that’s not you.’ So we were created with a piece of divinity inside us, but with this thing called free will, and I think God watches us every day, lovingly, praying we will make the right choices.
59. The story of my recent life. I like that phrase. It makes more sense than the story of my life, because we get so many lives between birth and death. A life to be a child. A life to come of age. A life to wander, to settle, to fall in love, to parent, to test our promise, to realize our mortality—and, in some lucky cases, to do something after that realization.
60. It’s not me against the other guy. It’s God measuring you against you. Maybe all you get are chances to do good, and what little bad you do ain’t much bad at all. But because God has put you in the position where you can always do good, when you do something bad—it’s like you let God down. And maybe people who only get chances to do bad, always around bad things, like us, when they finally make something good out of it, God’s happy.
61. If you could pack for heaven, this was how you’d do it, touching everything, taking nothing.
62. A: Mitch, it does no good to be angry or carry grudges. It churns you up inside. It does you more harm than the object of your anger
B: So let it go?
A: Or don’t let it get started in the first place. You know what I found over the years? When I had a disagreement with someone, and they came to talk to me, I always.began by saying, ‘I’ve thought about it. And in some ways maybe you’re right’. Now, I didn’t always believe that. But it made things easier. Right from the start, they relaxed. A negotiation could take place. I took a volatile situation and, what’s the word…?
B: Defused it?
A: Defused it. We need to do that. Especially with family.
63. You know, in our tradition, we ask forgiveness from everyone—even casual acquaintances. But with those we are closest with wives, children, parents—we too often let things linger. Don’t wait, Mitch. It’s such a waste.
64. Nothing haunts like the things we don’t say.
65. "I will give you a new heart and put a new spirit in you; I will remove from you your heart of stone and give you a heart of flesh" (Ezekiel 36:26).
66. I thought about how churches and synagogues usually build memberships. Some run schools. Some host social events. Some offer singles nights, lecture series, carnivals, and sign-up drives. Annual dues are part of the equation. At I Am My Brother’s Keeper, there were no dues, no drives, no singles nights. Membership grew the old-fashioned way: a desperate need for God.
67. I’m where I’m supposed to be.
68. A: I sermonize about wanting cherries when you’re planting lemons, but I’ve planted many lemons in my life...and I may not have reaped all that harvest
B: I don’t understand. If you think you’re going to be punished—
A: Why still serve God? What else can I do? It’s like when everyone was turning away, and Jesus asked the apostles, ‘Will you go, too?’ And Peter said, ‘Where can I go, Lord?’ I know what he meant. Where do you go from God? He’s everywhere.
69. You can’t work your way into heaven. Anytime you try and justify yourself with works, you disqualify yourself with works. What I do here, every day, for the rest of my life, is only my way of saying, ‘Lord, regardless of what eternity holds for me, let me give something back to You. I know it don’t even no scorecard. But let me make something of my life before I go…And then, Lord, I’m at Your mercy.’
70. I realized something as I drove home that night: that I am neither better nor smarter, only luckier. And I should be ashamed of thinking I knew everything, because you can know the whole world and still feel lost in it. So many people are in pain—no matter how smart or accomplished—they cry, they yearn, they hurt. But instead of looking down on things, they look up, which is where I should have been looking, too. Because when the world quiets to the sound of your own breathing, we all want the same things: comfort, love, and a peaceful heart.
71. Scripture says, “Judge not.” But God had the right to, and Henry lived with that every day. It was enough.
72. Henry was right. At that moment, it didn’t matter what name you used. God is good.